You're ₹499 away from free shipping.

Best & compared

Sheba Melty Alternatives in India: 6 Creamy Treats

Looking for a Sheba Melty alternative? Six creamy cat treats compared on label, preservatives and where they are made, including Cleos Real Tuna.

By Saan & Shradha · 30 October 2026 · 4 min read

A cat licking a Cleos Real Tuna creamy treat from a hand

Sheba Melty is the creamy treat most cat parents in India have tried. Cats love it, it is easy to find, and the little sachets are fun. So why do people go looking for alternatives?

What people usually want instead

Looking at what shoppers ask, the same four reasons come up:

  • A preservative on the label. Indian retailer pages for Sheba Melty list EDTA and sodium nitrite.
  • Water listed first. Several Melty listings start with water, then chicken, then tuna or katsuo. That is normal for creamy treats, but it means you cannot tell how much meat is inside.
  • An imported product. Melty sold in India is imported and marketed by Mars International India, with Thailand listed as the origin.
  • Variety. Some cats get bored of one flavour.

Sheba Melty is not a bad treat. If your cat loves it and you are happy with the label, keep going. If one of the points above is why you are here, read on.

Six alternatives

1. Cleos Real Tuna

  • Label (back of pack): Tuna Meat, Water, Modified Tapioca Starch, Xanthan Gum, Yeast Extract, Sodium Alginate, Inulin, L-Taurine, Vitamin E.
  • Why switch: Tuna meat is listed first, and there are no preservatives and no by-products. Made in India, 15 g tubes, four to a pack.
  • Consider: Cleos prints a maximum of 79% moisture, against up to 90% on Melty. Both are soft and creamy, and both use thickeners for the texture.

See Real Tuna

2. Cleos Real Tuna & Shrimp

  • Label (back of pack): Tuna Meat, Water, Modified Tapioca Starch, Shrimp Meat, Xanthan Gum, Yeast Extract, Sodium Alginate, Inulin, L-Taurine, Vitamin E.
  • Why switch: The nearest thing to a Melty "tuna and prawn" for a cat that likes a change.

See Real Tuna & Shrimp

3. Inaba Churu

  • Label (international listings): Water, Chicken or Tuna, Tapioca Starch, Natural Flavors, Guar Gum, Vitamin E, Taurine, Green Tea Extract.
  • Why switch: No preservative is listed on the listings we found.
  • Consider: Water comes first, and the Indian pack may differ, so read it.

4. Drools Creamy Treats (Tuna and Bonito)

  • Label: Retailer pages mention taurine, vitamins and minerals. We did not find a full ingredient list for the tuna flavour, so read the pack.
  • Why switch: Made in India, and easy to find.

5. Temptations Creamy Purrrr-ee

  • Label: Listings include meat, thickeners (modified starch, guar gum, xanthan gum), flavour and a preservative.
  • Why switch: Flavours like salmon and cheese are different from Melty.
  • Consider: The preservative is listed, so this does not solve the preservative problem.

6. Grain Zero Creamy Treats (Tuna and Ocean Fish)

  • Label: Described as grain, GMO and gluten free. We could not find the full ingredient list.
  • Why switch: For cats that need a grain-free option.

The quick pick

If you want Try
No preservatives and meat named first Cleos Real Tuna
A change from tuna Cleos Real Tuna & Shrimp
The other treat everyone compares to Inaba Churu
A cheese or salmon flavour Temptations Creamy
Made in India and easy to find Drools or Cleos

Checked 30 October 2026 from Indian retailer listings and, for Churu, international listings. Brand names belong to their owners. Formulas change, so always read the pack in your hand. Spotted an error? Email feedback@getcleos.in and we will fix it.

How to switch without a fuss

Cats can be dramatic about change. A gentle swap:

  1. Offer a lick of the new treat off your finger first.
  2. Keep the old one for the next day or two, so nothing feels taken away.
  3. Watch for a settled tummy before you offer more.
  4. Not sure which flavour? The Bonding Box has one pack of every Cleos flavour, so your cat decides.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Sheba Melty safe for cats?

Cats eat it every day without trouble, and it is sold widely in India. This page is about preferences, such as no preservatives or meat named first, not about it being unsafe. Ask your vet if your cat has a health condition.

What is the best Sheba Melty alternative in India?

It depends on what you want to change. For no preservatives and tuna named first, try Cleos Real Tuna. For a similar creamy treat from an established brand, try Inaba Churu.

Does Sheba Melty have preservatives?

Indian retailer listings show EDTA and sodium nitrite. Labels can change, so check the pack you buy.

How is Cleos different from Sheba Melty?

Cleos Real Tuna lists tuna meat first, then water, with no preservatives. Melty listings start with water and include a preservative. See the full side-by-side.

Meet Real Tuna

Straight from the sea.

Real tuna, named first on the label. Ingredients: Tuna Meat, Water, Modified Tapioca Starch, Xanthan Gum, Yeast Extract, Sodium Alginate, Inulin, L-Taurine, Vitamin E. No by-products, no preservatives.

Real Tuna creamy cat treats by Cleos

Waitlist open

Want first dibs for your cat?

Cleos is launching soon. Join the waitlist for early access to our creamy cat treats, plus launch-day perks.

Join the waitlist
Saan and Shradha with their orange Persian cat, Cleo

Written by

Saan & Shradha, cat parents to Cleo

We make Cleos creamy cat treats in India. We're not vets, so for anything about your cat's health, ask yours. Our story

Found this useful? Share it