Cleos vs Inaba Churu vs Sheba Melty: Labels Compared
Cleos, Inaba Churu and Sheba Melty side by side: what is listed first, preservatives, added flavour, protein and tube size.
By Saan & Shradha · 30 October 2026 · 4 min read

Inaba Churu is the creamy treat everyone measures against. Sheba Melty is the one most Indian cat parents have tried. We make Cleos, and we wanted to put all three side by side, label to label, so you do not have to take anyone's word for it.
How we compared
We looked at printed ingredient lists and guaranteed analysis, not taste (your cat is the only judge of that). We compared like with like: chicken against chicken, tuna against tuna.
Sources: the Cleos back-of-pack label, and Indian retailer listings checked 30 October 2026. We could not find a label for Churu as sold in India, so its figures come from international retailer listings. Formulas and packs change, so always read the pack in your hand.
Chicken: Cleos Real Chicken vs Inaba Churu Chicken Recipe
| Cleos Real Chicken | Inaba Churu Chicken Recipe | |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Chicken Meat, Water, Modified Tapioca Starch, Xanthan Gum, Yeast Extract, Sodium Alginate, Inulin, L-Taurine, Vitamin E | Water, Chicken, Tapioca Starch, Natural Flavors, Natural Scallop Flavor, Guar Gum, Vitamin E, Taurine, Green Tea Extract |
| First ingredient | Chicken Meat | Water |
| Preservative | None | None listed |
| Added flavour | Yeast extract | Natural flavors |
| Protein (as printed) | min 13% | min 7% |
| Tube size | 15 g | 14 g |
Fair to Churu: it has no preservative, adds taurine and vitamin E, and cats love it. The label is cleaner than most.
Where Cleos is different: meat is listed first, there are no by-products, and it is made in India. Both use a starch and thickeners for the creamy texture.
Tuna: Cleos Real Tuna vs Sheba Melty Tuna
| Cleos Real Tuna | Sheba Melty Tuna | |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Tuna Meat, Water, Modified Tapioca Starch, Xanthan Gum, Yeast Extract, Sodium Alginate, Inulin, L-Taurine, Vitamin E | Water, Chicken, Tuna or Katsuo, Modified Starch, Guar Gum, Xanthan Gum, Flavour, EDTA, Sodium Nitrite |
| First ingredient | Tuna Meat | Water |
| Preservative | None | Listed (EDTA, sodium nitrite) |
| Protein (as printed) | min 13% | min 5% |
| Moisture (as printed) | max 79% | max 90% |
| Sachet or tube | 15 g | 12 g |
Fair to Sheba: it is easy to find, cats like it, and the little sachets are easy to use.
Where Cleos is different: meat is first and there is no preservative. Melty prints a higher moisture figure, so the protein gap is partly water. The better comparison is the ingredient list.
What the numbers mean
- Water first is normal for creamy treats. It is not a sign of a bad treat, but it does mean the meat is not the largest ingredient by weight.
- A preservative is not dangerous by default. Many cats eat treats with them every day. If you prefer a label without one, that is a fair thing to look for.
- Protein figures are "as printed". Treats with more water show lower protein, so compare lists, not just percentages.
- Every creamy treat has a thickener. Cleos uses xanthan gum and sodium alginate, Churu uses guar gum, Melty uses guar and xanthan gum. They give the creamy texture.
Which should you pick?
- Your cat loves Churu: stay with Churu, or add Cleos for variety.
- You want meat named first, no by-products and no preservatives: Cleos.
- Your cat loves Melty and you are happy with the label: nothing wrong with that. If you ever want a change, see Sheba Melty alternatives.
- You are not sure: The Bonding Box has all four Cleos flavours, 16 tubes, so you can see which one your cat comes back for.
Want the wider picture? See our comparison of the best creamy cat treats in India.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cleos better than Inaba Churu?
They are both good treats. The difference on the label is that Cleos Real Chicken lists chicken meat first, while Churu lists water first. Neither lists a preservative. Your cat has the final say.
Is Cleos better than Sheba Melty?
On the label: Cleos Real Tuna lists tuna meat first with no preservatives, and Melty lists water first with a preservative. Taste is for your cat to decide.
Do Cleos treats have preservatives?
No. The tubes are cooked and sealed under heat and pressure, the same method used for canned human food, so nothing is added to keep them safe.
Are Cleos treats made in India?
Yes, made in India with real meat and no by-products.
The Bonding Box
Not sure which flavour? Let your cat choose.
One pack of every flavour, 16 creamy tubes. Made with real meat, no by-products, no preservatives.

Waitlist open
Want first dibs for your cat?
Cleos is launching soon. Join the waitlist for early access to our creamy cat treats, plus launch-day perks.
Join the waitlist
Written by
Saan & Shradha, cat parents to Cleo
We make Cleos creamy cat treats in India. We're not vets, so for anything about your cat's health, ask yours. Our story
Found this useful? Share it
Keep reading

Best Creamy Cat Treats in India (2026): 7 Compared
Seven creamy cat treats sold in India compared on what is listed first, preservatives and added flavour. Includes Cleos, Inaba Churu, Sheba Melty and more.
Read more →

Sheba Melty Alternatives in India: 6 Creamy Treats
Looking for a Sheba Melty alternative? Six creamy cat treats compared on label, preservatives and where they are made, including Cleos Real Tuna.
Read more →

Best Cat Treats for Kittens (and When to Start)
When can kittens have treats, how much is too much and what to look for. Cleos creamy treats are fine from 12 weeks, in small amounts.
Read more →